AccueilCommuniquéOpen letter against the Belo Monte hydroelectric dam project on the Xingu River, Brazil.

Open letter against the Belo Monte hydroelectric dam project on the Xingu River, Brazil.

Texte seulement disponible en anglais
Your Excellency President Luis Ignácio Lula da Silva,

We’re writing you to express our indignation and urge you to immediately suspend the Belo Monte hydroelectric dam project on the Xingu River in the state of Pará due to the tremendous social, environmental, and economic risks posed by this project to the Amazon Region.

In July of 2009, you met with representatives of Brazilian civil society and leaders of Indigenous communities from the Xingu River basin in Brasilia, promising them renewed dialogue on the looming mega-project and assuring them that “Belo Monte will not be shoved down anyone’s throat.” We understood this to mean that Belo Monte would only be approved once affected communities had been adequately consulted about the project, understood its implications, and consented to its construction.

Yet less than a year later, your government has given the green light to the project, despite the outrage of local communities as well as glaring concerns and warnings by Brazilian experts. Even two senior officials at IBAMA, Leozildo Tabajara da Silva Benjamin and Sebastião Custódio Pires, resigned their posts last year, citing high-level political pressure to approve the project. It is clear that there are serious concerns and criticisms originating from numerous groups and figures within Brazilian civil society, including Dom Erwin Krautler, the Catholic Church’s National Council of Brazilian Bishops (CNBB), Leonardo Boff, and many others. Regardless of these concerns from your fellow Brazilians and your earlier promise to them, we see that your government indeed intends to shove Belo Monte down the throats of the directly affected Indigenous and riverine communities in the Amazon.

We are not only extremely concerned with the decision to build such an enormous, environmentally destructive mega-project, but also with the unethical process through which the government excluded civil society from any kind of open debate. Those who stand to be most impacted by the construction of this project – the people of the lower Xingu River – were particularly kept out of the decision-making process. The people of the Xingu Basin have fought Belo Monte for more than 20 years on the same grounds that they continue to oppose it now.

As you know, Brazil voted for the United Nations Declaration on the Rights of Indigenous Peoples (UNDRIP), which enshrines their right to self-determination, including free, prior and informed consent, and is now considered part of International Human Rights norms. Brazil is also a party to Convention 169 of the International Labor Organization which guarantees Indigenous peoples the right to free, prior and informed consultation to development or infrastructure projects that will impact their lives and livelihoods, such as the proposed Belo Monte dam. Leaders of local Indigenous groups have made it clear that this right was completely disregarded in approving Belo Monte and sanctioning its impacts on Indigenous territories.

Traditional populations and Indigenous peoples have had their rights violated during this entire process, and we urge you to remedy this situation. We believe the construction of Belo Monte represents the serious violation of nearly every article of UNDRIP, such as Articles 3, 4, 5, 7, 8, 9, 10, 11, 18, 19, 20, 24, 25, 26, 27, 28, 29, 32, 38, 40, 43, 44. Brazil is also in violation of Article 231.3, Chapter VIII, of its own 1988 Constitution, which legally guarantees Indigenous Peoples’ right to challenge the exploitation of water resources on their lands, and of Article 10-V of CONAMA resolution 237 (19 December 1997), which requires public consultation of environmental impact assessments.

As you are aware, the Belo Monte dam will inundate some 500 square km of land, and divert nearly the entire flow of the Xingu through two artificial canals to the dam’s powerhouse. This alone will leave Indigenous and traditional communities along a 130 km stretch of the Volta Grande without water, fish, or a means of river transport. The lowering of the water table would destroy the agricultural production of the region, affecting Indigenous and non-Indigenous farmers, as well as water quality. In all probability, the rainforests in this region would not survive. The formation of small, stagnant pools of water among the rocks of the Volta Grande will be a prime environment for the proliferation of malaria and other water-borne diseases. Communities upstream, including the Kayapó Indians, will suffer the loss of migratory fish species that are a crucial part of their diet.

In addition to these devastating impacts to the Volta Grande, an estimated 20,000 people will be forced from their homes, including inhabitants of the city of Altamira, which will be partially flooded. In spite of this, Belo Monte is held up as a model for your government’s ambitious Program for Acceleration and Growth (PAC) program, which promises a future for Brazil’s development with minimal social and environmental impacts. We join the Brazilian opponents to Belo Monte in saying these impacts are an unacceptable price to pay for a project of dubious economic and technical viability that offers questionable benefits to the Brazilian public. Indeed, it risks calling PAC’s entire image into question both in Brazil and worldwide, as the building of the Belo Monte dam would be completely contrary to the sustainable development and social benefits it espouses.

Independent investigations have found that the project’s environmental impact assessment is incomplete and underestimates the extent of Belo Monte’s potential impacts.  While it’s known that the flow along the Volta Grande of the Xingú would be seriously reduced by the canals; water quality, instream flow, and geological studies for the Volta Grande are still incomplete. Francisco Hernandez, an electrical engineer and co-coordinator of a group of 40 specialists who analyzed the project, doubts Belo Monte’s engineering viability and warns that this extremely complex project would depend on the construction of not only one dam, but rather a series of large dams and dykes that would interrupt the flow of water courses over an enormous area, requiring excavation of earth and rocks on the scale of digging the Panama Canal. We are particularly concerned with the disregard the government has shown to the opinions of the specialist panel as well as technical analysis issued by IBAMA last November, which is a fundamental piece of the environmental licensing process.

Belo Monte will generate only 10% of its stated installed capacity of 11,233 MW during the three to four-month dry season. Furthermore, there is uncertainty over the total costs of the project; while the Empresa de Pesquisa Energética estimates R$16 billion, private investors estimate R$30 billion.  The project’s inefficient energy supply and uncertainties over incomplete environmental data do not justify such an enormous investment. We are appalled by the lack of responsibility of corporate and financial actors that seek to materialize this project, such as Brazil’s national development bank BNDES, which is irresponsibly planning to use public taxpayer funding to finance the majority of Belo Monte. Belo Monte is not only a bad predicament for the people of the Xingu, it is a bad investment for Brazil.

The Belo Monte project is being pursued at the expense of viable and less destructive alternatives such as improvements in energy efficiency, and the promotion of renewable energy such as solar and wind. A WWF-Brazil study published in 2007 showed that by 2020 Brazil could cut the expected demand for electricity by 40% through investments in energy efficiency. The power saved would be equivalent to 14 Belo Monte hydroelectric plants, and would save Brazil around R$33 billion in the process.

While viable and sustainable alternatives do exist, Belo Monte is being proposed as a model for Brazil’s renewable energy matrix, an important part of the country’s 38% reduction in domestic emissions by 2020. In fact, the opposite is true: the dam will emit large quantities of methane, a greenhouse gas that is 21 times more potent than C02. Big dams also cause considerable direct and indirect environmental destruction, such as widespread deforestation and an increase in emissions. There is nothing clean or sustainable about Belo Monte.

We believe your meeting last July was a very positive step towards opening new channels of dialogue and trust between your government and local populations on the Xingu River. However, we are seeing that the stark failure to follow through on this promise for dialogue is pushing this issue towards a boiling point, with the prospect of mass mobilizations and violent confrontations growing closer to reality every day.

In conclusion, we see your government’s approval of this mega-project as a highly irresponsible and reckless act. Forcing Belo Monte down the throats of thousands of Indigenous peoples and riverine families, while laying waste to the lower Xingu River, is an immeasurably high price to pay for an inefficient, costly and environmentally devastating form of electricity.

Brazil does not need Belo Monte to secure its energy future.

We strongly urge your government to adopt less-destructive alternatives to fuel Brazil’s economic growth, perform adequate consultation with local communities, and to immediately suspend this disastrous project out of respect for the rights of the inhabitants of the Xingu River and the integrity of the region’s ecosystem.

ACTION POPULAIRE CONTRE LA MONDIALISATION, Geneva, Switzerland

ASIAN INDIGENOUS WOMENS’S NETWORK, Philippines

ASIA PACIFIC INDIGENOUS YOUTH NETWORK, Philippines

ASOCIACIÓN DE ECOLOGÍA

ACCION ECOLOGICA REDLAR

ASOCIACION INTERAMERICANA PARA DEFENSA DEL AMBIENTE

AFRICA YOUTH INITIATIVE ON CLIMATE CHANGE

AKIN

ALLIANCA DEL CLIMA E.V.

AMAZON WATCH

AMBIENTE E SALUTE (ENVIRONMENT AND HEALTH), Bolzano-Italy

AMNESTY INTERNATIONAL, Lateinamerica, Berlin

ANAKU ERMET, Aotearora

AQUATIC NETWORK

ASIA INDIGENOUS PEOPLES PACT

BERNE DECLARATION, Switzerland

BIOFUELWATCH

Both ENDS

BUILDING COMMUNITY VOICES, Cambodia

CANADIANS FOR ACTION ON CLIMATE CHANGE

CARBON TRADE WATCH

CENTRE FOR CIVIL SOCIETY ENVIRONMENTAL JUSTICE PROJECT, Durban, South Africa

CENTER FOR INDIGENOUS PEOPLES, Pakistan

CHR-CAR, China

CLIMATE ALLIANCE OF EUROPEAN CITIES WITH THE INDIGENOUS RAINFOREST PEOPLES

CODEPINK

COECOCEIBA-FoE Costa Rica

COMITÉ POUR LES DROITS HUMAINS EN AMÉRIQUE LATINE

COMUNIDAD VILLA SALVIANI, Bolivia

CORDILLERA PEOPLES ALLIANCE, Philipines

CORPORATE ACCOUNTABILITY INTERNATIONAL

CORPORATE ETHICS INTERNATIONAL

COUNCIL OF CANADIANS

DOGWOOD ALLIANCE

EARTH CHARTER NARSAQ, Greenland

EARTH CHARTER YOUTH VISION ALLIANCE NETWORK, Nigeria

EARTHPEOPLES

ECO LABS UK

ECOSISTEMAS, Chile

FERN

FIAN, Netherlands

FLEMISH CENTRE FOR INDIGENOUS PEOPLES, Belgium

ECOLOGISTAS EN ACCIÓN

ENERGY ETHICS, Denmark

ENVIROCARE, Tanzania

FRIENDS OF PEOPLES CLOSE TO NATURE

FRIENDS OF THE EARTH, Austria

FRIENDS OF THE EARTH, Canada

FRIENDS OF THE EARTH, Cyprus

FRIENDS OF THE EARTH, Flanders and Brussels

FRIENDS OF THE EARTH, France

FRIENDS OF THE EARTH, Mauritius

FRIENDS OF THE EARTH, Sierra Leone.

FRIENDS OF THE EARTH U.S.

FUNDACIÓN PARA ADHESIÓN CON LOS PUEBLOS AMAZÓNICOS

Fundación PROTEGER, Argentina

GegenStrömung – CounterCurrent

GLOBAL EXCHANGE

GLOBAL FOREST COALITION

GLOBAL JUSTICE ECOLOGY PROJECT

GLOBAL 2000 – FRIENDS OF THE EARTH, Austria

GRASSROOTS INTERNATIONAL

GREEN ACTION FOE, Croatia

GREENPEACE

GRUPPO AMBIENTE, Bolzano, Italy

HMONG ASSOCIATION, Thailand

HUMAN RIGHTS PROJECT AT THE URBAN JUSTICE CENTER

IBIZA ECOLOGIC

ILO, Support for Indigenous Peoples, Cambodia

INDIAN CONFEDERATION OF INDIGENOUS AND TRIBAL PEOPLES NORTH EAST ZONE

INDIAN YOUTH CLIMATE NETWORK

INDIGENOUS ENVIRONMENTAL NETWORK

INDIGENOUS PEOPLES COUNCIL ON BIOCOLONIALISM

INDIGENOUS PEOPLES CULTURAL SUPPORT TRUST

INDIGENOUS RIGHTS ACTIVE MEMBER, Cambodia

INDI-GENEVE, Switzerland

INDONESIA FISHERFOLK UNION/Serikat Nelayan Indonesia (SNI)

INSTITUTE FOR SOCIAL ECOLOGY

INTERNATIONAL ACCOUNTABILITY PROJECT, USA

INTERNATIONAL RIVERS

IPUGAO TRIBAL GROUP, Philippines

JUSTICE, PEACE AND INTEGRATION IN CREATION

KAHAB ABORIGINAL ASSOCIATION OF NANFOU, Taiwan

KALUMARAN – ALLIANCA OF INDIGENOUS PEOPLES ORGANIZATIONS MNDANAU

KIRAT YAKTHUNG MANGENNA CHUMLUNG, Nepal

Klima-Bündnis

KOALISYON NG KATUTUKO , Philipines

KoBra

LAND IS LIFE

LISIANG DONGBA CULTURE RESEARCH INSTITUTE, China

MAGAR STUDIES CENTER, Nepal

MENSCHENRECHTE 3000 e.V. (Human Rights 3000)

MINA SUSANA SETRA, Indonesia

MONTAGNARD FOUNDATION, Vietnam

NAGA PEOPLES MOVEMENT FOR HUMAN RIGHTS, Philippines

NATIONAL ASSOCIATION OF PROFESSIONAL ENVIRONMENTALISTS, Uganda

NETHERLANDS CENTRE FOR INDIGENOUS PEOPLES

NETWORK OF INDIGENOUS PEOPLES IN THAILAND

NOAH Friends of the Earth Denmark

NURHIDAYAT MOENIR, Indonesia

ODISHA ADIVASI MANCH, India

OILWATCH, Costa Rica

OILWATCH, Mesoamerica

O’odham VOICE Against the WALL

PACIFIC ENVIRONMENT

PACIFIC INDIGENOUS PEOPLES ENVIRONMENTAL COALITION

PAGGAMISAN TAKO AM, Philippines

PAKISTAN FISHERFOLK FORUM

PEACE ACTION MAINE, USA

PENGON-FOE Palestine

PERUVIAN IN ACTION-NY

PUMC-UNAM sede Oaxaca

QIVI NETWORK GREENLAND

RADIO DIGNIDAD

RADIO URGENTE

RAINFOREST ACTION NETWORK

RETTET DEN REGENWALD e.V

SOBREVIVENCIA FRIENDS OF THE EARTH, Paraguay

SOCIETY FOR THREATENED PEOPLES INTERNATIONAL

SOS-REGENWALD, Austria

TARA-Ping Pu, Taiwan

TAIWAN ENVIRONMENTAL PROTECTION UNION

TERRA NOSSA FOUNDATION

THE CORNER HOUSE

THE ENVIRO SHOW WXOJ-LP & WMCB

THE WITTENBERG CENTER FOR ALTERNATIVE RESOURCES

TIBET THIRD POLE

TIMOR-LESTE INSTITUTE FOR DEVELOPMENT MONITORING AND ANALYSIS-La’o Hamutu

TRAPESE POPULAR EDUCATION COLLECTIVE

TRIBAL PROFESSIONAL AND TUDENT SOLIDARITY, Southern Mindanao

UMPHILO WAMANZI, A WATER AND ENVIRONMENTAL CSO IN SOUTH AFRICA

UNITED WORLD OF INDIGENOUS PEOPLES

Universitario México Nación Multicultural –UNAM

VIVAT International

VOICE, Bangladesh

VOLUNTARY SERVICES ONESEAS, Pakistan

WISEREARTH

WORLD RAINFOREST MOVEMENT

YACHAY WASI, Cuzco, Peru & NYC, USA